Skip to main content

Book Review: Making Dystopia

A review of James Stevens Curl's Making Dystopia by Nikos A. Salingaros.
Making Dystopia book cover

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through affiliate links.

Making Dystopia: The Strange Rise and Survival of Architectural Barbarism by James Stevens Curl

Introduction by Timothy Brittain-Catlin Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK, 2018
592 pages; 72 b&w illustrations;
39 figures; $60
ISBN: 9780198753698

Can a text on architectural history, however thoroughly researched and brilliantly written, trigger an architectural revolution? For a discipline in ferment, this might just provide the jolt to set off an avalanche.

Making Dystopia demolishes the legitimacy through which a peculiarly inhuman aesthetic has dominated architectural culture during one century. That includes the latest designs by our Starchitects.

This book presents a comprehensive history of the Bauhaus, of Le Corbusier, the Soviet Constructivists, etc. Those defined the “look” that architecture has conformed to ever since, within an extremely limited palette of variations. Professor Curl lays out how anti-establishment movements at the start of the 20th century generated forces clamoring for a “new” architecture. He traces the unlikely success of anti-traditional design aesthetics as they coagulated into the International Style. Much of this history as presented in “standard” texts has been falsified.

East Wing of the Royal Ontario Museum in Toronto, Ontario

The East Wing of the Royal Ontario Museum in Toronto, Ontario, Canada (1933), was designed by the distinguished Canadian architectural firm of Chapman & Oxley, in a late Byzantino-Romanesque Revival style. It is seemingly being gobbled up by the Deconstructivist ‘Michael Lee-Chin Crystal’ extension (2002–07), designed by Studio Daniel Libeskind, in collaboration with Canadian architects Bregman & Hamann (later B+H Architects). This expensive Deconstructivist addition was not entirely free from problems associated with the weather (from a drawing of 2016 ©JSC).

Claims for styles evolving from premodernist architects turn out to be invented. Professor Curl debunks the commonly-cited “good intentions” of modernist pioneers: The reality is a freakish mixture of cult beliefs and ruthless egos. Most disturbing is the complete disdain for human biology. The modernists offer the building industry a cheap way of constructing massive high-density buildings for maximal profit. Grateful real-estate speculators and powerful car manufacturers exclusively promoted this architectural style in the media.

Today’s dominant architectural idiom descends directly from those early disruptive ideas, while traditional buildings remain on the banned list. Society accepts this absolutist situation as inevitable.

This iconoclastic landmark book might change the way we build from now on. It’s an outstanding work of scholarship that needs to be read by every architect and architecture student who still possesses a conscience.

Buying Guide Spotlight

Cambek™ Designer Doors Custom Carriage House Style Garage Doors

Cambek - Designer Doors ◆

Cambek™- Designer Doors® is a manufacturer of fine custom entry doors, garage doors, and matching millwork.

Related Articles

“The Angles of the Sainte Chapelle steeple were the second hardest to photograph,” says the author. She used a 300mm lens to capture many of her images and for this one she carried her ladder on a Paris bus. The steeple was added in the mid-19th century to the 13th-century church.

Book Review: Angels of Paris

A Book Review of Angels of Paris: An Architectural Tour through the History of Paris by Rosemary Flannery

Ken Tate residence, Classicist No. 13

Book Review: Classicist No. 13

Read the review of Classicist No. 13 by Peter H. Miller, president, Home Group, Active Interest Media.

Forest Hills Gardens in New York City’s borough of Queens is one of America’s most successful urban garden villages. Begun in 1907 to a plan by Frederick Law Olmsted, Jr., with architecture by Grosvenor Atterbury, the center of the community is built around its Station Square connection to the Long Island Railroad – shown here with the tower of the Forest Hills Inn in the background.

Book Review: Paradise Planned

The first comprehensive review of nearly two centuries of the garden suburb movement in Europe and the U.S.